Finding the right investment property involves the strategic review of rental potential, expenses, and neighbourhood trends. Today, we’re going to explore several factors to account for when you make this critical decision.
How to Find the Right Investment Property
From property condition to local demand, each section below outlines what to evaluate before making an offer.
Clarify Your Real Estate Investment Goals and Budget
First things first, you need to establish clear goals and a realistic budget. The right property depends on your strategy. For example, long-term rentals require stable, high-demand areas, while flipping calls for undervalued homes with room for improvement.
Budget for more than the purchase price. Investment properties often require a down payment of 20% to 30%, plus closing and ongoing costs. Check your credit and arrange financing early to focus your search on properties you can afford.
Location and Neighbourhood: Key Factors in Finding the Right Property
It’s often said that the three most important factors in real estate are “location, location, location,” – and this adage holds true for investment properties. The location of a rental property greatly influences its profitability and long-term value.
Pay close attention to the neighbourhood and surrounding area and make note of the:
Neighbourhood profile: The neighbourhood will determine the types of tenants you attract and the rental demand. Match the location to the type of renter and income you want.
Safety and crime rates: High-crime areas are, understandably, not the most appealing. Review local crime data to learn more about the neighbourhood you’re considering. Visit the area at different times to get a feel for it.
Local amenities and job market: Locations with access to parks, schools, transit, and shopping appeal to renters. A healthy job market sustains rental demand and can contribute to rising property values.
Vacancy rates and rental demand: What is the local rental supply like? If there are too many vacant units, this could translate to weak demand or seasonal fluctuations. On the contrary, areas with low vacancy rates mean landlords can be more selective and maintain stronger rental income.
A gorgeous investment property in a poor location can be a challenge, whereas a decent property in a great location often turns out to be a solid investment.
Evaluate the Numbers: Rental Income, Expenses, and Property Taxes
Before you make your decision, you need to crunch the numbers to know the investment makes financial sense. You’ll want to estimate the potential rental income and weigh it against all the expenses associated with the property:
Estimate rental income: Research local rents for similar properties (same area, size, and amenities) to gauge how much income you can reasonably expect. Set a realistic rent to avoid long vacancies. Focus on whether the expected rent will cover costs and produce cash flow.
Calculate all expenses: List every cost you will face as a landlord: mortgage, insurance, property taxes, repairs, condo fees, and utilities, if applicable. Subtract these from your expected rent to see if the property will cash flow. If it does not, it may not be a sustainable investment property.
Consider property taxes carefully: Property taxes vary by location and can eat into your profits. High taxes may be manageable in strong rental markets, but in weaker areas, they can make a property unprofitable. Check the local tax rate, current assessment, and whether increases are expected.
Maintenance and repair costs: All properties need upkeep, and older ones often require more. Budget for annual repairs—some use a rule like 1% of the property’s value. Assess the condition of major systems. DIY work saves money but takes time and skills. Hiring pros adds cost but reduces effort.
Ultimately, what to look for in the financials is a real estate investment that cash flows positively. A healthy investment property is one where the rent exceeds the sum of mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, and upkeep. This way, you’re left with a profit each month.
Property Condition and Value-Add Potential
When scouting for the right investment property, take a hard look at the property’s physical condition and its potential for value growth.
A property isn’t only a passive investment. Rather, it’s a tangible asset that will require maintenance, and you’ll often be able to improve it to increase its profitability.
Inspection and condition: Always inspect the property (ideally with a professional home inspector) to identify any red flags. A fixer-upper may be affordable, but it could strain your budget and timeline. A property in better condition may cost more upfront, but typically requires less work.
New construction vs. existing property: Consider whether you want a brand-new property or an older, established one. New builds often require fewer repairs but come with a higher price tag. Existing homes can be more affordable and may offer a rental history, established landscaping, and proven utility performance.
Value-add opportunities: Savvy real estate investors often seek properties with value-add potential. Minor updates like paint, new appliances, or landscaping can raise the rental value. Finishing a basement or adding a unit can also increase income.
Appreciation potential: While cash flow is king for rental properties, don’t ignore the potential for the property’s value to grow. Strong locations and local development can lead to appreciation. Compare recent sale prices in the area to understand trends.
The main takeaway is to choose a rental property that is in sound condition or one where you’re prepared (and able) to handle the work it needs.
Property Management: Will You Hire a Property Manager or DIY?
An often overlooked aspect of finding the right investment property is considering how you will manage it after purchase.
Being a landlord comes with responsibilities, and you should decide upfront whether you’ll handle them yourself or hire a property manager. This decision can influence what kind of property you buy and where it’s located.
Keep these things in mind while you make your decision:
Distance and effort: Planning to self-manage? Then, choose a property within reasonable driving distance. Then, handling showings, maintenance, and inspections will be a lot more manageable since the property is close.
What property managers do: A property management company takes care of advertising, screening tenants, collecting rent, coordinating repairs, and even evictions for you. The typical fee is 8% to 12% of the monthly rental income. While the cost may reduce your margins, this move can pay off in time saved and improved tenant satisfaction.
Hands-on management considerations: Now, if you plan to skip the property manager, be ready to take on marketing, tenant screening, and coordinating repairs yourself. You’ll have more control and you’ll save some money on property management fees, but it requires time, patience, and a basic understanding of landlord responsibilities.
There is no right or wrong choice here – some investors love the hands-on aspect, while others treat their investment purely as a financial asset and outsource the rest.
Bonus Tips for Finding the Right Investment Property
Choosing an investment property is no small decision, but with detailed research and a clear plan, you’ll find the right property.
As you compare properties, keep these final tips in mind:
Do your homework: Diligence is fundamental. Investigate every aspect – the neighbourhood, the local market trends, the property’s history, and its financials. It takes time to find the right combination of city, neighbourhood, and property. Be thorough and avoid rushing into a deal without a full understanding of what you’re buying.
Stay realistic: Keep your expectations grounded. Real estate investments require patience and planning. Assume some vacancy and repair costs along the way. Be prepared with financial reserves to cover early expenses before the property starts generating consistent rental income.
Learn from others: If you’re new to real estate investing, seek advice from experienced investors or agents. Join local groups or partner with someone who knows the business. They can help you spot issues and opportunities you might miss on your own.
Trust the numbers, not emotions: It’s easy to get attached to a house, but this is a business decision. Let the math guide your choice. A less attractive property with better financials may outperform a prettier one with weaker returns.
Take the Next Step Toward Real Estate Investing
A good investment property supports your income goals, fits your financial plan, and has room to grow in value. Finding the right one takes time, planning, and a clear look at both the numbers and the neighbourhood.
Each factor we’ve covered today—rental income, expenses, condition, and management—shapes how well the property performs over time.
When you're ready to move forward, iCash can help with flexible funding options. Whether you need extra capital for closing costs, repairs, or financial reserves, we make it easier to prepare for your next move in real estate.
Contact iCash to see how we can help support your investment property goals.
Here are three more articles to read next:
